Chesterfield Township Voters Reject Police Tax, Pass Fire Millages
Supervisor Michael Lovelock and Treasurer Linda Hartman were re-elected while newcomer Cindy Berry won bid for clerk.
- By Christy Arboscello
- Email the author
- November 7, 2012
Photos
Pdfs
Chesterfield Township residents rejected the proposed police tax hike that was supposed to prevent major layoffs on the force. Meanwhile, township voters approved the fire tax renewal and millages.
With 100 percent of the precincts reporting, the police tax was turned down by 52.3 percent of voters and favored by 47.7 percent. The fire tax renewal and increase was flipped, with 47.7 rejecting it and 52.3 approving. The equipment millage passed with 56 percent of the vote, according to unofficial county election results and the Chesterfield Township Clerk's Office.
Meanwhile, incumbent Supervisor Michael Lovelock, a Democrat, scored another four years in office while Republican challenger Cindy Berry unseated incumbent Clerk Jan Uglis, a Democrat, in a close race. Democrat incumbent Treasurer Linda Hartman maintained office against Republican Kathy Elliott, in another tight race, while Trustee incumbents Brian (Scott) DeMuynck and Christine Bell and newcomers Henry Anderson and David Joseph won seats, the results show.
See full results in the chart and check back with Patch for more election news.
Updated, 2 a.m. Wednesday
Most of Chesterfield Township went to bed Tuesday night unsure whether the tax proposals for police and fire passed.
By 2 a.m., only 45 percent of the precincts were reporting results. At that time, 51.1 percent of voters rejected the police millage while 48.9 percent approved it. With the same amount of precincts reporting, 53.1 percent were in favor of the fire renewal and increase while 46.9 percent turned it down, according to unofficial county election results.
The fire equipment, apparatus and housing millage got 55.9 percent approval and 44.1 rejection with 45 percent of the precincts reporting, the results show.
While the ballot proposals were close in the early morning hours, it won't be clear whether they passed until 100 percent of the precincts report votes.
Check back with Patch for complete election results.
Updated, 9:30 p.m. Tuesday
Chesterfield Township candidates are eagerly awaiting results while the fate of the police and fire tax proposals will be unveiled tonight.
Chesterfield Township Supervisor Michael Lovelock gathered with friends and supporters at Zuccaro's Banquets and Catering on Gratiot. If re-elected he hopes to present a balanced township budget to the new board in the next two years and convert vacant land into baseball and soccer parks, he said.
He pointed to new retail growth, such as Menard's and Dunham's Sports as positive steps for the community.
"We are working with the businesses," Lovelock said. "We are doing everything we can to bring them to Chesterfield."
He thanked no-party affiliate candidate Joe Miller for running against him.
"Joe Miller, as far as I'm concerned, ran a clean campaign," he said, adding Miller "was doing his civic duty" by challenging in him in the race.
Meanwhile, at Zuccaro's, Police Chief Bruce Smith said officers encouraging police tax proposal at precincts reported positive feedback from voters.
"For the most part, it was overwhelming support," Smith said.
At Little Camille's By the Bay, County Commissioner Kathy Vosburg, of Chesterfield, awaited results with fellow Republicans, State Rep. Andrea LaFontaine and Chesterfield treasurer candidate Kathy Elliott.
"I was energized just being at the polls and voting," Vosburg said.
She said everyone was patient in the morning during the hour-long line at Green Elementary.
LaFontaine said she spent the day at four Chesterfield precincts as well as Columbus, Ira and Kimball townships.
"I am optimistic but still nervous at the same time," she said.
Elliott said, "I did everything that I could, so I'm at peace with the results. It's up to the people."
Updated, 6:30 p.m.
Chesterfield Township Clerk Jan Uglis said there's been high voter turnout throughout the day, with some precincts seeing around 600 residents each well before polls close at 8 p.m.
Uglis said she expects registered voter turnout will be in the high 70th percentile, exceeding the last presidential election cycle. Absentee ballots comprise 18 percent of Chesterfield's registered voters this election.
The Democratic clerk, who is running for re-election against Republican Cindy Berry, said she's been too busy with election duties to dwell on her bid for office.
“I feel good, but it’s not up to me. The man upstairs is the one who’s going to tell me where I’m going to be," Uglis said. “I only hope that this township gets a good board that can work together."
Updated, 1:20 p.m.
Chesterfield Township resident Karlee Schulte, who turns 26 Wednesday, voted at Chesterfield Municipal Offices on Sugarbush.
"I just wanted to contribute," said Schulte. "I am pulling for Romney because I feel that not much has changed with Obama in office."
Retired Chesterfield Township Police Lt. Dave Marker hands out magnets to voters outside the township offices to show support of the police proposal on the ballot. Marker is joined by firefighter representatives who also hope to sway voters to passing the renewal and increase for the fire department.
Update, 11:30 a.m.
Chesterfield Township Firefighter Rick Gadd and Fire Capt. Doug Calvert stand outside Fire Station 3 with signs in favor of the fire tax proposals. Resident Denise Calvert, who's married to Doug Calvert, said she voted absentee to avoid lines and to take time mulling over the various state proposals.
She said she voted for Barack Obama because, "I don't believe that the economy is as bad as they say it is...It takes a long time for an economy to come back. It's not going to be instant like going to Burger King for a hamburger."
In New Baltimore, a multi-vehicle accident delayed traffic on Green Street as voters headed to Precincts 1 and 2 outside the Rec Center on Washington. Clerk Marcia Shinska said lines were moving quickly throughout the city and about 30 percent of the city's total registered voters had already cast their ballots.
New Baltimore resident Susan Sheare, 55, said she came to the precinct on Washington to support collective bargaining rights and also for another four years of Obama.
"He's done a great job," she said of Obama, adding it takes time to improve the economy. "I don't like the two-sidedness of Romney. You can't change your mind on everything all the time."
Update, 10:30 a.m.
Voters waited an average of an hour to cast their ballots at Precinct 6 at the Department of Public Works building in Chesterfield Township. There, fire department representatives waived signs to encourage voters to support the tax renewal and increase.
LIVE 2012 CHESTERFIELD TOWNSHIP ELECTION RESULTS
Check back with Patch for complete election results as they come in.
| Chesterfield Township Supervisor | Results |
| Michael Lovelock |
9,860 |
| Joe Miller |
6,228 |
| Chesterfield Township Clerk | Results |
| Cindy Berry |
9,532 |
| Jan Uglis |
9,489 |
| Chesterfield Township Treasurer | Results |
| Kathy Elliott |
9,235 |
| Linda Hartman |
9,438 |
| Chesterfield Township Trustee, 4 positions | Results |
| Henry Anderson |
8,430 |
| Brian Scott DeMuynck |
9,082 |
| Cyndi Gagleard |
7,986 |
| David M. Joseph |
8,345 |
| Christine Bell |
9,043 |
| John Grivas | 8,068 |
| Keith Nelson |
7,916 |
| Tom Scott | 7,692 |
| Township Library Board of Directors, 6 positions | Results |
| Murney R. Bell |
5,259 |
| Loraine DeMuynck |
7,419 |
| Kermit Harris | 5,244 |
| Michael A. Miller | 6,707 |
| Ralph Musilli | 4,781 |
| Alan D. Naldrett | 6,683 |
| Dorothy Stabile | 7,029 |
| Chesterfield Township Police Protection Millage | Results |
| Yes | 9,502 |
| No | 10,431 |
| Chesterfield Township Fire Protection Millage | Results |
| Yes | 10,416 |
| No | 9,509 |
| Chesterfield Township Fire Equipment Millage | Results |
| Yes | 11,088 |
| No | 8,715 |
| L'Anse Creuse Schools | Results |
| Charles W. Eslinger | 8,440 |
| Earl Fuller Jr. | 6,371 |
| Mary L. Hilton | 10,284 |
| Sharon L. McTavish Ross 8,632 |
| Anchor Bay Schools Board, 2 positions | Results |
| Diane Caldwell |
7,395 |
| G. Rowena LenHausen | 4,218 |
| Terri Villiancourt | 6,094 |
| Macomb County Commissioner, 8th District |
Results |
| Jeff DiPascale, Democrat |
11,621 |
| Kathy D. Vosburg, Republican |
15,478 |
| State Representative, 32nd District | Results |
| Sherri Smith, Democrat | 11,115 |
| Andrea LaFontaine, Republican | 13,876 |
LIVE 2012 NEW BALTIMORE ELECTION RESULTS
Check back with Patch for complete election results as they come in.
| Anchor Bay Schools Board, 2 positions | Results |
| Diane Caldwell |
7,395 |
| G. Rowena LenHausen | 4,218 |
| Terri Villiancourt | 6,094 |
| Macomb County Commissioner, 8th District |
Results |
| Jeff DiPascale, Democrat |
11,621 |
| Kathy D. Vosburg, Republican |
15,478 |
|
State Representative, 32nd District |
Results |
| Sherri Smith, Democrat | 11,115 |
| Andrea LaFontaine, Republican | 13,876 |
Follow live coverage of Macomb County results and Michigan election results here. Connect with New Baltimore-Chesterfield Township Patch on Facebook and Twitter.
Tell us about your experience at the polls in the comments' section below.
Read More in Elections
Michigan Election 2012: Stabenow Captures Senate SeatIn This article
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
Zuccaro Banquets & Catering
46601 Gratiot Ave, Chesterfield, MI42.642337-82.854506Zuccaro Banquets & Catering
46601 Gratiot Ave, Chesterfield, MI586-949-4110/listings/zuccaro-banquets-catering1529855/locations/1858578 -
-
-
Green Elementary School
47260 Sugarbush Rd, Chesterfield, MI42.647702-82.820064Green Elementary School
47260 Sugarbush Rd, Chesterfield, MI586-493-5280/listings/green-elementary-school-21529714/locations/1858434 -
-
See More on Patch
Most Popular articles
- Chesterfield Splash Park Grand Opening in June
- Chesterfield Township Splash Park, New Baltimore Harbor, Detroit Tigers PAWS Pitches In
- Passenger Accused of Pointing Gun During Road Rage Incident by Hall Road
- Levin, Miller Weigh in on Obamacare Repeal Vote
- New Baltimore to Celebrate New Harbor, Patrol Boat
Christy Arboscello
7:08 am on Tuesday, November 6, 2012
Please share your experiences at the polls today in the comments' section.
kidcat24
8:10 am on Wednesday, November 7, 2012
Oh good more minimum wage service jobs. Time to get some more good paying manufacturing jobs in New Baltimore/Chesterfield.
kidcat24
8:10 am on Wednesday, November 7, 2012
Now we get the sheriffs patrolling our city, lovely
Biscuit Shredder
8:10 am on Wednesday, November 7, 2012
You people are unbelievable. No on the police? Fools
Princess524
10:53 am on Wednesday, November 7, 2012
I think people would have accepted the proposal more if we didn't feel so strong armed! Over 200 a year more for 20 years is what people could not swallow. Had they did half and half then address the proposal again in 10 years then I belive it would have passed.
Most people are struggling to make ends meet now! We do not know thier situation divorced,widowed, layed off, there are so many reasons that a house hold did not vote yes.
I for one feel as though the city will "find" money to keep the police on!
I believe there are areas that money can be budgeted better and the city officials will need to do thier jobs to take a little give a little to make it happen!
If it don't happen then there is noone to blame but the majority of Chesterfield so time will tell .
I for one don't think people that voted no should be called stupid or hated on by others . It was thier choice to vote as they pleased, just like the ones voted yes.
So all the negitivty should be kept to a personal opinion and why you are saddened in the situation not vent out on others by name calling. WE ALL HAVE THE RIGHT TO VOTE!
Over Taxed
10:53 am on Wednesday, November 7, 2012
Why are we already paying 3 times the amount our surrounding communities are paying, for police? Chesterfield residents are tired of getting raked over the coals, and getting little for the dollars we pay, for everything. It is time for the funds to be properly appropriated.
Darlene Luce
10:53 am on Wednesday, November 7, 2012
Channell 4 News said it passed!!!
Christy Arboscello
10:57 am on Wednesday, November 7, 2012
Although there have been conflicting media reports that the police millage passed, the Macomb County election results, Chesterfield Township Clerk's Office and Chesterfield Township Police Chief Bruce Smith confirm it failed. Check back with us for additional election news stories today.
Biscuit Shredder
11:00 am on Wednesday, November 7, 2012
$200 a year is nothing. Give me a break. $200 a year is not eating out a couple times a month. Is that not worth giving up? Give up you Netflix and other BS. I'm not falling for the "everyone is struggling". Get out of the house and look around. Everyone I see has an iPhone or a northface jacket.
Marc B
11:21 am on Wednesday, November 7, 2012
My issue was that it was not an incremental increase for a set time period. It was a gimme for a lifetime. Other communities were looking for an increase for the next 5 years or so. To me, that is tolerable because I would of voted for a 5 year mill increase that would of ended at a set time period. We could then evaluate the situation 3 - 4 years down the road and see if we need to re-up the mill or dial it back down as property values and commercial will increase in the township. Taking a blind eye to it until it is too late is a failure in the making!
I fault the current elected officials for their shortsightedness regarding this proposal and subsequent failure. Its now time for them to really hunker down and figure it out. If the township would view itself on how a small business owner looks at their business, we would focus on the issues and find short-term and long-term solutions and not take the easy road and look for a bailout that would cover us far passed our elected years. This includes everything from benefits, salaries, community sharing services..etc. The days of $5 medical co-pays and glorious benefits are long gone.
Princess524
11:21 am on Wednesday, November 7, 2012
I'm happy to know 200 is nothing to you! Maybe you should donate it, but my own experience I don't have a iPhone I don't have cable and the last time I ate out was June so "people struggle" I'm not gonna pass judgement on others but people have it hard. I can not remember the last time I bought my self anything!
I'm not on public assistance because I pay my bills with what I have budgeted! Now extra 200 a year would and could have more people on public assistance then what?
WITH GAS PRICES AS HIGH AS THE GOT THIS YEAR WE STILL HAVE TO PAY THAT BUT OUR PAYCHECKS DON'T INCREASE . so any extra money goes to gas and groceries
My bills and my daughter come first!!!!
now 2 years ago I was in a much better position I had a 2 family income
So please quit being rude some people just don't have the means
Biscuit Shredder
11:44 am on Wednesday, November 7, 2012
So you're not a real princess I guess
Princess524
11:44 am on Wednesday, November 7, 2012
100 % marc!!!
Princess524
11:53 am on Wednesday, November 7, 2012
Really???? No I guess not but that's what I call my daughter she does not need to worry about money. Every little girl deserves to feel like a pricess poor or rich . So quit sobbing because you "lost" and drive up and down 23 mile throwing those 100 bills you have laying around so us poor folks can go grab them ;)
Biscuit Shredder
2:30 pm on Wednesday, November 7, 2012
Lol
Maximus Max
7:14 pm on Wednesday, November 7, 2012
Thanks for posting this! I knew I would be able to find this here rather than waiting a week for the Voice!
Hey Biscuit, can you please post a description of your car? I need a little extra spending money too!
Princess524
7:37 pm on Wednesday, November 7, 2012
Lmao ;)
cyberrick
8:02 am on Thursday, November 8, 2012
Sheriff does a good job in Macomb Twp and the way I see it we will actually be saving money by using them instead.
Biscuit Shredder
9:44 pm on Thursday, November 8, 2012
I never said I throw money around. I stated my observations. Im sure there are families legitimately struggling. I also stated I my opinion on making up the $200 a year. I would be happy to frequent the local jimmy johns or Rosie's less if it meant keeping the staff up at the police dept. people go on and on about fair shares and all that nonsenical BS but when it comes down to it they say to themselves "but not for me" and vote accordingly.
jason
10:30 am on Tuesday, November 20, 2012
Know anyone that lives in harrison twp? No on sheriff patrols...