Should Chesterfield Police, Fire Millages Pass?
Chesterfield Township residents will decide the fate of the police and fire departments' funding Tuesday.
- By Christy Arboscello
- Email the author
- November 5, 2012
Photos
Pdfs
Chesterfield Township voters will decide Tuesday whether to approve increased funding for police and fire departments.
Their Nov. 6 general election vote will follow months of anticipation in the community regarding the ballot proposals.
Fire tax renewal, increase
Last January, Fire Chief Doug Charbonneau told Patch declining property values resulting in smaller collections on the existing taxes means the department needs more money. A requested tax increase comes at the same time of the existing millage renewal.
A committee—comprising Trustees Brian (Scott) DeMuynck, Michele Ficht and Gerald Alexie, Charbonneau, Union President and firefighter Gordon Tuzinsky and Union Vice President Fire Lt. Brian Hubbert—formed in spring to review the department's financial needs.
In summer, the Board of Trustees greenlit ballot language for the fire and police departments on the November ballot.
The fire department will ask voters to renew the existing mills, along with a .75 mill increase. The additional .75 mills will be added to the previously collected 2 mills for operations. The previously collected .5 mills for equipment will be also be on the ballot for renewal. If approved, the tax collection would be in effect for 20 years. Fire officials held special meetings in fall to answer questions about the tax request.
Fire and township officials say the ballot must pass to sustain the department that's already operating at low staffing levels.
Police millage request
Chesterfield Township police and board members say more tax revenue is crucial for the department.
A financial audit last summer showed the police fund is expected to be completely depleted in four to five years.
During the 2011 financial audit by Plante and Moran, auditors told the township that the overall community received an "unqualified audit opinion"—essentially the gold star rating—for sound financial management. But, the police department suffered an $870,000 operating loss because of an 18 percent decline in property values.
"This is a long-term problem," township Finance Director Victoria Bauer previously said.
During town hall meetings last month, police officials told the public that major layoffs were expected if the millage didn't pass. "Up to 40 percent of the department's patrol staff may be laid off in 2014 if funding is not approved. The patrol staff may be reduced from 43 to 26 officers. This reduction will result in increased emergency response times and elimination of some not in-progress/non-crime related services," according to the presentation.
The police department already collects 5 mills that do not require renewal. Voters will be asked to approve another 2.5 mills that would be also be collected annually in perpetuity. The proposed increase will mean an average home owner will pay $200 a year, according to the department.
Resident reaction is mixed
Chesterfield Township voters have been torn over the millage proposals. In comments on Patch and on our Facebook page, some say they favor the tax hikes to sustain police and fire services in the community of more than 43,000 residents. While others criticize the collection amount, or the 20-year millage for fire and endless collection on the police tax.
"I question why 20 long years," longtime resident Joe Miller, who is running for township supervisor, told the board in August.
Supervisor Michael Lovelock, who is running for re-election, dismissed talks of disbanding the police force for the Macomb County Sheriff's Office.
"I feel strongly in my police and fire departments and I will do everything in my power to keep the police and fire departments in Chesterfield."
In part of a Facebook post, voter Rick Kotecki wrote, "During hard times everyone is asked to do more with less, when will this apply to our local government?"
Meanwhile, many homeowners in the community posted yard signs for the millages. And, some residents attended township meetings to vocalize their support.
"I think our police department is one of the finest in the state," said Rene Nelson said in summer. "I would take everything I have to pay a higher tax to keep our police department. I'm sure that 90 percent of Chesterfield residents would."
Read the exact ballot language for the police and fire proposals in our November Election Guide.
What do you think about the ballot proposals? Tell us in the comments' section below.
Read More in Elections
Week in Review: Teen Robbed at Gunpoint, Blood Donations Needed, Anchor Bay Kids Help CauseIn This article
See moreSee More on Patch
Most Popular articles
- Chesterfield Splash Park Grand Opening in June
- Chesterfield Township Splash Park, New Baltimore Harbor, Detroit Tigers PAWS Pitches In
- Passenger Accused of Pointing Gun During Road Rage Incident by Hall Road
- Levin, Miller Weigh in on Obamacare Repeal Vote
- New Baltimore to Celebrate New Harbor, Patrol Boat
Tracy - Chesterfield Twp
8:52 am on Monday, November 5, 2012
I have to say, Rick Kotecki's comment set me off.
Unfortunately, criminals don't stop committing crimes during economically hard times, it actually increases. More people out of work, more people turning to theft and drugs, more people becoming desperate.
How can you even think of cutting the police force when now is the time when we need them most? We need (not want) a quick response time. We need (not want) more than just a few officers on the road at a time.
Im sure Mr Kotecki is a nice man but - His comment showed his ignorance and his asinine way of thinking. He must not have common sense. A decrease in local (police) government would be extremely harmful to our health, welfare and property values.
Margaret Szczesniak
11:52 am on Monday, November 5, 2012
Enough of raping the homeowners! This mileage is nothing but for the personal benefits of the employees union! They want to secure their great pension & benefits while the rest of us "lay" people who are fortunate to even have a job scrape to get by! VOTE NO ON BOTH POLICE & FIRE MILEAGES, I DID!
l.c.
5:26 pm on Monday, November 5, 2012
Margaret....if you would like to work afts, mids, holidays etc and put your life on the line every day you too could get one of these great pensions you talk about. When you call 911 you want trained professionals to show up. Sounds like misery loves company.
Concerned Citizen
5:26 pm on Monday, November 5, 2012
The Fire Millage for building, equipment and apparatus is a renewal since it expires in 2013. The other Fire Millage is a renewal with a .75% increase to cover costs associated with the loss of revenue from housing decline. If it is not passed, we will not have a fire department since the millage also expires in 2013. We will ALWAYS need a fire department.
As for the police millage, it housing had not crashed, we wouldn't have lost 2.3 Million in revenue and would not be asking for an increase. Even when housing improves, our values will only go up 5% or the rate of inflation each year and it will take 18 years to get back to where we were in 2007. WE WILL ALWAYS NEED THE POLICE DEPARTMENT.
PLEASE VOTE YES ON NOVEMBER 6TH. WE NEED FIRE AND POLICE PROTECTION.