.
Feedback

Frustrated New Baltimore Official Announces Plans to Resign

The councilman's decision came after a council majority voted to repeal a police contract.

Longtime New Baltimore Councilman Jeffrey Christie announced plans to resign Monday night to a surprised council.

"I will be tendering my resignation before the next meeting," Christie said at the end of regularly scheduled session in city hall. "I'm done."

Mayor Larry Smith said he was sorry to hear the news, but added he understood.

Christie's announcement came shortly after Councilwoman Florence Hayman successfully motioned to repeal a ratified police contract for command officers, namely lieutenant and sergeant ranks, in the city.

Hayman had the matter added to the agenda during the meeting. However, city attorney Robert Hribar recommended against it. He said the city would be better off publishing the item on the agenda with advance notification.

"I appreciate his input, but it doesn't change my decision," Hayman said.

After the council approved to repeal the contract—with its contents not discussed openly—Christie turned to Hayman with choice words.

"That's absolutely the sneakiest thing you've ever done. You know that?" he said. "You just cost the city thousands and thousands of dollars."

She responded, "I'm sure Mr. Dolan can sort it out," referring to another one of the city's lawyers, Jack Dolan.

Smith said, "I question if that's even legal for us to do."

Hayman said after the meeting she sought to repeal the contract because the command officers changed union representation amid negotiations. That switch in representation from the Command Officers Association of Michigan (COAM) to another union was ignored by the city administration, she contends.

"Because of that, it is my belief that their prior union didn't have the authority to negotiate the contract," she said.

The contract was finalized and did not include any major concessions, Smith said after the meeting.

"I am just flabbergasted," he said.

Councilwoman Susan Burkhardt, who like Christie, voted against repealing the contract.

"My thoughts are: we pay a city attorney and when he makes a recommendation, I am going to heed that recommendation," she said.

Christie, who sat on council for approximately two decades, left the meeting without comment. He was expected to run for re-election this year.

Check back with Patch for more news out of the council meeting.

Debra February 26, 2013 at 02:47 am
I hope the union sues her personally. What an idiot
Kristen McFarland February 26, 2013 at 02:57 am
The city of New Baltimore will be going down the drain, just Like Detroit.
KM February 26, 2013 at 03:12 am
I think Flo Hayman needs to be stopped..the woman is so angry and belligerent at every meeting...She intimidates people, is disrespectful to citizens and is just outright mean. I want all the council members who voted for this to explain why they are using my tax dollars to pay for city attorneys and then not listen to their advice...I think we need to RECALL these members
Foxy Lady February 26, 2013 at 07:10 am
God bless the council for doing the right thing!!!!!!!!! Back room closed door underhanded deals will not stand! The truth will be told!!!
willowmina February 26, 2013 at 12:44 pm
Sounds like Detroit city council not New Baltimore. People take note of the names here when you go to vote, or we will have the same kind of mess they have in Detroit.
Bruce Ritchie February 26, 2013 at 01:31 pm
I am going to asume your real name is not Foxy Lady, as you are talking about closed door deals. What I saw last night was 4 council members doing a closed door, underhanded deal. There was no mention of why Hayman wanted to repeal the ratification of the contract, but only legal advice not to do so in such a way. However, 3 other council members supported her. One she is working together with to get the second elected to Mayor. She must have spoke to them prior to the meeting for them to support such a motion against legal advice. But her rationale was not heard in the public forum.
Do you not see the closed door, underhandedness of what Hayman, Butler, Dupray and Rutledge did?
Patrick Russell February 26, 2013 at 01:36 pm
New Baltimore's residents had a opportunity for change by having a lot of new faces to chose from last election. Instead, they chose just one young kid who decided he would use the city as a stepping stone for his political career and he resigned within a few months. Next election, get out with the old and in with the new. With new council comes fresh ideas on what is truly important to the residents of New Baltimore. You have a great mayor, now build around him! Nuff said, good day!
J. Harris February 26, 2013 at 04:05 pm
As I am sorry to see Jeff leave, I do support the council voiding the command contract as it was not propperly handled. I see many pro and negative comments here, but the facts will eventually come to light. So regardless if you like Council women Hayman or not or if you support the city or not, I am sure this will all be resolved. I wish all parties involved the best of luck. -
Jane February 26, 2013 at 04:27 pm
I say shame on all of them for not doing their homework in the first place. We elected these people to do a job and they vote on contracts and other things without knowledge of what they are voting on. Then they freak out when they realize it was something they should have not voted on anyhow. No wonder businesses are fleeing our poor little town! With leadership like that what businesses would want to come here and deal with that political mess?
Bruce Ritchie February 26, 2013 at 06:13 pm
@ Rapid_Fire_1, the vote was to repeal the resolution which ratified the contract with COAM, not POAM. Hayman said in this article that the officer's were changing representation in the middle of negotiations. I am not a lawyer, but with my dealings with unions, it is my understanding that such a change is illegal. The Mayor should have ignored it. Why wouldn't Hayman state the reason for wanting to repeal something that was just approved? How did 3 other Council Members vote on yes something without having heard any rationale? Unless there were conversations that violated the open meetings act.
rapid_fire_1 February 26, 2013 at 06:51 pm
Flo Hayman has the integrity of her convictions. The Mayor deceived council by ratifying a contract without the knowledge or vote of the command officer's union membership. The command officers were changing unions, Mayor Smith knew that, and POAM knew that. POAM signed a contract on the Mayor's terms so they could force the command membership to 3 more years of paying union dues (under the union security clause) to a union that didn't represent them, and the Mayor got a contract without having to bargain in good faith. What the Mayor and POAM did is called an unfair labor practice. Council did not create this, Mayor Smith and POAM did. Their behavior was so arbitrary it shocks the conscience, and they will have to deal with the consequences of their actions. We are so fortunate to have council members who have the integrity to do the right thing, even in the face of such adversity.
rapid_fire_1 February 26, 2013 at 07:07 pm
Bruce, the POAM was the bargaining agent for the command (COA) and patrol (POA) units. Council vote was to repeal the COA contract. The COA had not entered negotiations with the City, and were free to seek other representation. The POAM and the Mayor Smith went behind the COA's back, and without their knowledge ratified a contract COA didn't even know about until the deal was done. POAM and Mayor Smith did this after learning the COA was jumping ship.and had signed representation cards with another union.
Johnathon Jones February 26, 2013 at 09:23 pm
Rapid Fire's conscience is certainly shocked, more than once, which is why he probably referred to Hayman as having the integrity to do the right thing. Integrity and Flo are never used in the same sentence for a reason. She comes to meeting with an angry attitude and face to match just daring someone to say something so she can disagree and cause turmoil. She should have resigned, not Jeff Christie, at least he has common sense where she has none. She is too old and hostile to be on the council and her goal to get John Dupray in the Mayor's seat is the height of corruption. I thought the residents were suppose to decide who is elected Mayor not Hayman and Butler. So rapid fire, whoever you are (no name?) don't talk about Hayman and integrity. She has none. Neither does Butler. And you are probably a police officer angry about something in the contract which saves the residents money and maybe takes away one of your many perks.
James L February 26, 2013 at 10:07 pm
Wow, I'm in a union, and I can tell you our membership would have been furious. We would have sued the union for failure to represent, the the City for unfair labour practices. Maybe they will, I'm interested to see how this shakes out. WTG City Council, my hats off to ya!
Bruce Ritchie February 26, 2013 at 10:26 pm
@ Rapid_fire_1. If the command officers did't vote to ratify the contract it doesn't sound like there is one, for the council to vote on. If that is the case it would have been nice for Hayman to state her rationale, instead of looking the way she did. Maybe Rapid_fire_1 can fill her spot when she is recalled for running fundraisers for Mayor canidates. My concern is that Hayman and Butler, when they are not conflicting their interest, along with Dupray, are going to be appointing another lacky to fill Christy's spot.
Robert Thoms February 26, 2013 at 11:16 pm
The council did what was right in rescinding their vote on the union issue once they found out how the Mayor and the Union rep negotiated a contract without the command officers knowledge or approval. How unethical is that?? Isn't it also a coincidence that Mayor Smith and the POAM union rep used to work together at Fraser Police Dept??.. Seems like a conflict of interest to me along with another unethical decision by Mayor Smith. Sure seems like some unethical issues are involved here and needs to be looked into futher.. The New Baltimore council members voted on the contract after being mis-informed by Mayor Smith and once they discovered they had been duped decided to correct a MAJOR and unethical wrong doing caused by Mayor Smith.
teri February 26, 2013 at 11:44 pm
How would you know what homework that council does?????? They do do their homework, and spend a lot of time looking into matters for the City. State some facts.
teri February 26, 2013 at 11:45 pm
The facts Will come to light
jeffrey christie February 27, 2013 at 01:15 am
The only person posting that knows anything about this is Bruce Ritchie. Thank you for paying attention. You are spot on.
Jeff Christie
Terry Belden February 27, 2013 at 09:39 am
Flo Hayman and integrity should not be in the same sentence. She comes to the meetings ready to disagree with anything said by the Mayor. Her attitude is the same as her face, hostile and antagonistic. She is too old to be on the council, it would have been better for the city if she resigned not Jeff Christie then maybe the meetings could proceed with professionalism.
Shelly February 27, 2013 at 01:19 pm
Mr. Christie,
Please consider staying. Please don't throw us to the wolves there are SOME sensible people in NB that see right through Flos angry hostile face. We need more like you sir!
Robert Thoms February 27, 2013 at 05:07 pm
Whatever your feelings are for Councilwoman Flo Hayman, she was right to recommending to rescind the vote that was previously made two weeks ago. Councilman Butler & Dupray also saw the writing on the wall. Too bad Councilwoman Burkhardt can't think for herself and has to let an attorney decide for her. The only "sneaky thing" done was the Mayor and the POAM rep bringing a contract to the NB City Council for a vote when the Command Officers had never seen the contract or voted on it. Any idiot can see that this is totally sneaky and an unfair labor practice. The Mayor has been a bully since he took office. He forced Chief Bolgar to resign early so he could put his campaign manager in as Chief of Police. He fired the poor kid working for the Rec Dept so he could put Carlos Aprea in the position. He fired Judy Sproat via email. This Mayor is out of control and needs to be ousted. So Councilman Christie. Who really is sneaky?? I really hate to see you leave Councilman Chrisite because you have always been able to think for yourself but come on. Enough is enough of Mayor Larry Smith and his unethical antics.
KM February 27, 2013 at 08:48 pm
I agree with Mr. Christie...and by the way Mr. Christie..please stay..your the only person on that council with an ounce of integrity. I find it interesting that once again it's election season and the dirty tactics come out.....I remember last time one of our illustrious council people were spreading vicious lies and rumours about other candidates(figure out who that person is...it isn't difficult)...so instead of handling this like professionals they are grandstanding...of course all in the name of helping MR. Dupray get elected...Unfortunately Mr. Dupray is way out of his league with this group of snakes(and don't think for a minute these snakes aren't counting on that naivete) Mr. Dupray is a very nice man but has no chance against the likes of Hayman and Butler...
Robert Thoms February 28, 2013 at 12:29 am
Mr. Walsh and all City of New Baltimore Residents..
if you think Mayor Larry Smith has INTEGRITY then you better look the definition up in the dictionary... Look up the word scroundel.. cheat..liar.. sneak. Mayor Larry Smith's picture is right next to all those words.. John Dupray has integrity and guts.. he is honest and Will get the job done.. ethicallly and legally..Unlike Smith!
J. Jones February 28, 2013 at 02:14 pm
Whoa Robert Thoms, easy to say all that garbage about the Mayor but you don't mention one thing to back up your accusations. Sounds like you wanted something you didn't get so you're out for revenge. Since Mayor Smith won the first election by a large margin and no one ran against him in the second term (because they didn't have a chance to win) it appears that most of the residents are pleased with the job he is doing. He is involved with the community, shows up at almost every event that takes place in the city, has an open door policy and is well liked and professional when he interacts with the residents at council meetings. If you think he is such a bad mayor then why don't you take a shot at running against him? Your comments are as worthless as you appear to be.
Bruce Ritchie February 28, 2013 at 02:27 pm
Burkhardt voted against it because Hayman never stated a reason to repeal the resolution. The contract issue is for MERC to handle. The Council was presented a contract, which appeared to be legitimate and they approved it. I think Hayman use her position on the council for political gain and attack the Mayor. This makes the person she appointed to Council look better in his bid for Mayor. The issues with the contract are Employer Relations issues, to be handled by MERC, not City Council.
Mr. Thomas, Carols did not get the Rec Dir. job, as you said, to my understanding because he was not educationaly qualified. Rumor (for what ever that is worth) is that Judy, also not educationally qualified, was fired by email, because she did not come to work after she cost the city several thousands of dollars in a contract she was not authorized to sign. It sounds to me that the Mayor was wrong in signing a contract with someone that no longer represented the Command Officers, but I will still support him over someone appointed and managed by council members like Hayman and Butler, as I am embarrassed to have them represent me and my city. I don't even know Dupray, but won't vote for him because of who put him in the ring and how.
Gillian February 28, 2013 at 02:39 pm
Those of you questioning what is going on, there is only one true way to find out how this affected the command officers, and could ultimately affect our safety in New Baltimore - ASK A COMMAND OFICER. You may be surprised at their response. Things aren't always as they seem at city hall, and I don't mean council - the day to day city hall "Decisions" are made out of spite by some who are just looking to protect their own jobs.
KM February 28, 2013 at 11:19 pm
Gee Mr Thoms sounds like a campaign speech..gee wonder what your real name is...bet you have a council connection...btw no one is challenging the integrity of Dupray but he is weak...can't even stand up to Butler...he'll just be a puppet...As far as Mr. Smith..at least he attempts to make this city a better place unlike the ridiculous council we have had for decades that have done NOTHING..take a look around town...the only improvements we have are those that have come in under the present mayor
J. Jones March 1, 2013 at 02:11 pm
And things are not always as they seem in the Police Department, if you say that negotiating a contract for the Command Officers will affect our safety, what does that mean? Their job is to protect the residents of the city so they will not protect us if they don't get the benefits, pensions, overtime, etc. because of the signed contract?
The Mayor is in charge of the Police and Fire departments and it seems that it's always the Police who complain to the local papers. The Mayor is doing his job, the command and patrol officers should be doing theirs and that includes protecting the residents who pay them. They could go work in another city if they are not happy, bet there would be a lot of applicants happy to accept what was in the contract and realize that the economy dictates the Mayor's decisions.

Newsletter & Alerts

Get the best stories each day and important breaking news

Subscribe

Not from New Baltimore-Chesterfield Patch? Find your Local Patch »

Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors. Write a new post... What's up? Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell something
Audrey Tatarelli June 1, 2013 at 06:20 pm
chickens are a food source,as long as there is not a rooster making noise all the time. They areRead More not a
Audrey Tatarelli June 1, 2013 at 06:24 pm
a problem like loud stereos all day all night, people selling cars etc on their front lawn, homesRead More not being kept check out the house on Sugarbush 2 years a ladder on the roof and the schrubs and grass is over grown. I thought we paid some one to look out for things as stated. I want a refund.
Michelle Carpenter Valenti June 5, 2013 at 01:43 pm
Ridiculous!! If they are going to do that then Chesterfield needs to think about bringing in aRead More decent market, like Whole Foods. There is no where in this area to get decent healthy food!!!